Grandmother receives driving ban over Bromsgrove teen death

First published in News by

A 58-YEAR-old grandmother caused the death of a teenage cyclist from Bromsgrove in a mystery crash near Droitwich, a court heard.

Anthony Phillips died as he cycled on the pavement on the A38 near Droitwich and the cause of the accident will never be explained, Worcester Crown Court was told.

The 18-year-old mobile DJ was cycling from Droitwich back to his home in Bromsgrove with his good friend James McKnight at about 3.30pm on Friday, August 10, 2012, Walter Bealby, prosecuting, told the court. They stopped to light a cigarette before continuing uphill along the A38 opposite Chateau Impney.

James stopped to relight his cigarette and that could have saved his life as a Kia Picanto driven by Ruth Felce of Kyre Road, Tenbury Wells, inexplicably mounted the kerb and hit Anthony's bike. The collision threw him into the branches of the roadside trees and he suffered a serious head injury.

Felce was on her way to meet her granddaughter in McDonald's near the motorway junction and take her back to her home for the weekend, Mr Bealby said.

The same day or the day before, she had taken prescribed medication including an anti-depressant and a treatment for restless leg syndrome. Medical experts suggested these could have caused drowsiness but there was no evidence to suggest they had contributed to the crash.

She denied causing death by dangerous driving and the prosecution offered no evidence at the start of a scheduled trial. She pleaded guilty to the alternative charge of causing death by careless or inconsiderate driving.

Mr Bealby said the car had simply failed to fully negotiate a slight right hand bend up an incline and had left the road. Felce told police she recalled seeing the two friends on their bikes at the side of the road and then all she knew was there had been "a bang or a thud." She stopped the car and ran back to Anthony, a former North Bromsgrove High School pupil, who was airlifted to Queen Elizabeth Hospital but died from his injuries.

Jonas Hankin, defending, said Felce accepted she was legally responsible but no-one could explain what had resulted in the momentary inattention that caused the "tragic consequences".

He said she had three daughters and was of positive good character, employed as a carer for children with severe learning difficulties and working on a voluntarily basis as manager of a day care centre for the elderly.

"As a mother, she recognises the burden of taking the life of a child," he said. "It's a sentence from which she will never be released."

Judge Michael Cullum said it could have been a "double tragedy" if James McKnight had not stopped to relight his cigarette.

"We will never know what actually happened," he said.

Felce was given a 12 month community order with 150 hours of unpaid work and banned from driving for 12 months. The court heard she had voluntarily surrendered her driving licence to police the day after the accident just over two years ago.

She was also ordered to pay £1,200 towards costs.

Comments (1)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

8:54am Fri 29 Aug 14

ScaredAmoeba says...

Why no life driving ban?
Why no imprisonment?

Kill somebody and you're in real trouble, unless you use a car. then you are automatically entitled to the driver's discount. No prison, often only a token fine and unless you're very unlucky you get to keep your licence, often with no need for a retest.
*Terms and conditions apply. Motorist's discount does not apply under certain circumstances: if you're evading arrest; hit & run; uninsured; drunk; illegal drugs; grossly appalling driving; defective vehicle; using a phone (talking, texting, surfing the net, Facebook etc.); disqualified; & etc.
Why no life driving ban? Why no imprisonment? Kill somebody and you're in real trouble, unless you use a car. then you are automatically entitled to the driver's discount. No prison, often only a token fine and unless you're very unlucky you get to keep your licence, often with no need for a retest. *Terms and conditions apply. Motorist's discount does not apply under certain circumstances: if you're evading arrest; hit & run; uninsured; drunk; illegal drugs; grossly appalling driving; defective vehicle; using a phone (talking, texting, surfing the net, Facebook etc.); disqualified; & etc. ScaredAmoeba
  • Score: -11

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree